At Benny’s, we’re proud to be a neighborhood restaurant and strive to keep our doors open to as many guests as possible. To help create a welcoming and lively atmosphere, we reserve a limited number of tables for reservations, while the remainder of our dining room and bar seating is available for walk-ins on a first-come, first-served basis.

• Once the dining room and bar are full, our team will begin a waitlist and provide an estimated wait time. While you wait, we invite you to explore the local shops and enjoy the character of our eclectic neighborhood.

• In keeping with our traditional approach to hospitality, we are unable to accept reservation requests through social media.

• We kindly ask that your entire party arrive within 15 minutes of your reservation time. After that grace period, we may need to offer the table to guests on our waitlist or ask that seated guests begin ordering while the remainder of the party arrives.

• As a courtesy to all of our guests, we respectfully ask that parties adhere to the following dining timelines:

  • 2 guests - 1.15 hrs

  • 3-4 guests 1.30 hrs

  • 4-6 guests 1.45 hrs

Please note that due to the size of our dining room, we are unable to accommodate reservations for parties larger than six guests between Memorial Day Weekend and Labor Day Weekend.

For reservation inquiries, questions or concerns, please reach out to us at reservations@bennysmaine.com.